Home | Contact Us | Archive | Online Books | Subscribe
Jana Sangh Today | A Monthly Magazine

Hindu Masjids

An evangelist's heart went out to Benares


10. Christian Tears

The Europeans should clearly understand that this spirit of 'Mohammedanism is unchangeable, and that, if by any mischance, India should again come into the possession of men of this creed, all the churches and colleges and all the Mission institutions, would not be worth a week's purchase. So wrote Reverend Mathaw Atmore Sherring. The Muslims had done no harm to the Christians of British India. But he was so upset at the vandalism he saw in Benares that he could not help speaking out.

Reverend Sherring was a devout, and maybe a slightly bigoted evangelist member of the London Missionary Society. He was dead against idol worship. As he has written idolatry is a word denoting all that is wicked in imagination and impure in practice. Idolatry is a demon - an incarnation of all evil. And yet he said it woul, not be difficult, I believe, to find twenty temples in all Benares of the age of Aurangzeb, or from 1658 to 1707. The same unequal proportion of old temples, as compared with new, is visible throughout the whole of northern India. His description of the desecration of temples by the thousand, and their blatant conversion into either mosques, mausoleums, dargahs palaces or pleasure houses has to be seen to be believed.

In his view, if there is one circumstance respecting the Mohammedan period which Hindus remember better than another, it is the insulting pride of the Musulmans (sic), the outrages which they perpetrated upon their religious convictions, and the extensive spoilation of their temples and shrines. When we endeavour to ascertain what the Mohammedans have left to the Hindus of their ancient buildings in Benares, we are startled at the result of' our investigations. Although the city is bestrewn with temples, it is unlikely that there are many which are old.

Reverend Sherring continued, the diminutive size of nearly all the temples in India ercept for the south that exist is another powerful testimony to the stringency of the Mohammedan rule. It seems clear, that, for the most part, the emperors for bade the Hindus to build spacious temples, and suffered them to erect only small structures, of the size of  cages, for their idols, and these of no pretensions to beauty. The consequence is, that the Hindus of the present day, blindly following the example of their predecessors of two centuries ago, commonly build their religious edifices of the same dwarfish size as formerly. These observations speak volumes for the trauma that the Hindu psyche has suffered as a result of the impact of Islam.

Sherring appreciates that Muslims yearn to visit Mecca and the Christians desire to go on a pilgrimage to Jerusalem but the Hindu heart goes out to Benares. If the Hindus refer to any one city as their holiest, it is Benares. Yet, Aurangzeb thought it fit to change its name to Muhammadabad. The temple of Bisheswar, who was regarded as king of all the Hindu gods, was systematically demolished by Aurangzeb during the 17th century. The large collection of deities stored on a platforrn called the court of Mahadev on the northern side of the temple, were found from the debris. As recorded by Sherring, extensive remains of this ancient temple are still visible and they form a large portion of the western wall of the mosque which was built upon its site by the bigoted oppressor. Evidently, the former temple was much larger than the present one, which is really small for so important a shrine. But there was a reason for it.

The new temple was built at the behest of Rani Ahilyabai Holkar long after Aurangzeb's desecration. As already explained by Sherring, all the temples built during the Mohammaden rule in Benares had to be diminutive in size. It transpires that the demolition of temples was not inspired merely by a hatred for idolatory or by greed for loot. It was also driven by a desire to humiliate the Hindus. Or, else, how does one explain that the masjid built by Aurangzeb had to be bang next to the Gyan Vapi or the well of knowledge.

Incidentally, Sherring has also referred to Al-Beruni who is one of the important sources of Indian history: He came to India with Mahmud Ghazni. Although the Reverend doubts Al-Beruni's contention, nevertheless, he mentions that Ghazni reached as far as Benares during his ninth incursion into India. In 1194 AD, Shahabuddin, better known as Muhammad Ghauri, after defeating the Kannaujian monarch, Jaichand, marched to Benares where he is reported to have destroyed a thousand Hindu temples.

The author came across this interesting book on Benares by an extraordinary circumstance. The last time he went to the holy city, he happened to be accompanied by a dyed-in-the-wool Marxist, Sudhansu Chaki, who was at the Presidency College, Kolkata, with him during 1956. Over the years, he had told the author that he was an atheist. If he had a God, it was Karl Marx. No one else. About half an hour after both of us had reached the Kashi Vishwanath temple, the author found his friend's eyes full of tears. When the author asked him why, he said he had not imagined the extent to which the land of his forefathers had been vandalised. he was referring to the Gyan Vapi masjid. Some months after he returned to Kolkata he sent the author the volume!


Hindu Masjids
Prafull Goradia
The Challenge
1. The Conflict

Shuddhi in Stone
10. Christian Tears
11. Ataladevi Masjid
12. Four Vandals, One Temple
13. Bhojshala Masjid
14. Seven Temples Kept Buried
15. Adina Masjid
16. Jungle Pirbaba
17. Mandir and Dargah in One Building
18. Shuddhi by Govemment
19. Iconoclasm Continues in pakistan, Bangladesh and in Kashmir
2. Shuddhi by British
20. American Professor on Temple Desecration
3. Incomplete Shuddhi
4. Spontaneous Shuddhi
5. Waterloo of Aryavarta
6. Reclaimed Temple at Mahaban
7. Qutbuddin And 27 Mandirs
8. Instant Vandalism
9. Ghazni to Alamgir

Anti-Hindu Hindus
21. Ghazni and Nehru
22. Is A Communist Always Anti-Hindu?
23. Are Some Intellectuals Perverse?
24. Are Some Eminent Indians Anti-Hindu?
25. Ambedkar, a True Hindu
26. Swaraj Meant Saving the Khalifa
27. Archaeological Surveys
28. Hindu Future after Black Tuesday

Acknowledgements
1. Annexure I
2. Annexure II
3. Annexure III
4. Annexure IV

© janasangh.com 2017 Designed & Hosted by GreenMindz